The main consideration in scheduling cupcake games is that the NCAA has no rules about playing an equal number of home and away games - or how you share revenue with visiting teams. So, universities like Ohio State that sell out their 100,000 person stadium for every game gladly pay teams like Buffalo to give up one of their own home games to play at Ohio State.
The weaker opponent may be less of a draw for ESPN and television networks, but universities are largely shielded from the financial consequences of scheduling patsy opponents as they split television revenues with their conference. Colleges pay cupcake opponents $400,000 to over $1 million because an extra home game brings in as much as $4 million to $5 million in additional revenue for the biggest programs. And during a mediocre season, that extra victory could be the difference in earning six wins and a profitable trip to a postseason bowl game.
In return, small programs receive increased exposure, a pipe dream of victory, and a check for as much as two thirds of their football budget and 20% of their athletic budget in a single game. (Head coaches are sometimes literally handed a six or seven figure check after the game.)
Despite the opulence of elite college football programs, the financial logic of the exchange is just as necessary for the elite teams as their cupcake opponents. As Priceonomics wrote in a prior article about the NCAA:University presidents overwhelmingly view the high cost of athletics as a problem and athletic directors are busy cutting their budgets - a process only accelerated by the recession. Just over half of elite football and basketball programs turn a profit. Only 14 out of 120 athletic departments in the upper tier of Division I cover their costs. The remainder run a median deficit of $10 million.Of the schools in the top conferences, only a quarter play a balanced schedule of 6 home games and 6 away games. The remainder schedule a guarantee game in order to play 7 home games or a game at a neutral site where they can split ticket revenue with their opponent.
The small school players may often be victims on the field, but their administrators are in the position of power. Every major program wants to schedule their guarantee games in September as the pollsters that rank teams and influence bowl placements give less credence to early games. That means the supply of small schools with amenable schedules is limited. Ohio State’s athletic director told USA News "Sometimes they've got you over a barrel.”
Wednesday, August 28, 2013
The $1 Million Reason College Football Season Starts with Blowouts
Good post from the Priceonomics blog as to why there are so many lousey NCAA games to start the football season:
Tuesday, August 27, 2013
What the St. Pete Mayoral Election Results Mean for the Rays
Nothing.
Tuesday's St. Pete primary, which eliminated Kathleen Ford from the race, does nothing to shift the Stadium Saga.
That's because the two men with slightly different visions of how to handle the Stadium Saga are still in the running for the mayor's office. Incumbent Bill Foster (41% of votes) will face former City Councilman Rick Kriseman (39% of votes) in a November run-off, which could be much more consequential to the Rays.
Flashback: Foster's 2009 mayoral victory was considered a "win" for the Rays at the time
Tuesday's St. Pete primary, which eliminated Kathleen Ford from the race, does nothing to shift the Stadium Saga.
That's because the two men with slightly different visions of how to handle the Stadium Saga are still in the running for the mayor's office. Incumbent Bill Foster (41% of votes) will face former City Councilman Rick Kriseman (39% of votes) in a November run-off, which could be much more consequential to the Rays.
Flashback: Foster's 2009 mayoral victory was considered a "win" for the Rays at the time
Orlando Outrage Continues (From Just One Person??)
Jeffrey Billman from the Orlando Weekly has been banging his head against a wall lately, wondering why he's the only guy in town who seems outraged over the continued subsidies offered sports teams and stadiums in Orlando.
This week, he penned, "If you’re not pissed off, you’re not paying attention: What Orlando could learn from St. Petersburg’s war over The Lens." An excerpt:
This week, he penned, "If you’re not pissed off, you’re not paying attention: What Orlando could learn from St. Petersburg’s war over The Lens." An excerpt:
Here’s the thing: This isn’t a fight over public spending or corruption or anything nasty or sordid. It’s a battle—an entrenched, vituperative battle—over architecture. Architecture!
Contrast that to Orlando City Hall this morning, where we had yet another round of glad-handing and civic boosterism dressed up as a city council workshop. The performing arts center folks talked about how close they are to finishing this magnificent structure, just $25 million more, please. The Citrus Bowl backers promised the sun and the stars—NFL games! NCAA championships!—if only we’d add $12 million to their coffers. And then there was Orlando City Soccer, brandishing its $1.2 billion in economic impact and an MLS franchise if only taxpayers helped them build a spanking-new stadium.
...
And yet, there’s no outrage, no movement for change...not one commissioner questioned the fundamental wisdom of having taxpayers subsidize professional sports facilities (of course, that horse left the barn the day the Amway Center opened) or blinked an eye at Orlando City’s economic impact assertions, even though economists are nigh-unanimous in thinking such studies—commissioned by the team, for the team—are hogwash.
...
To be more specific, 85 percent of economists oppose taxpayer-subsidized stadiums. That, my soccer-loving friends, is a consensus, and it’s backed up by (most of) the economics literature. You don’t have to like the facts, but they are facts nonetheless.
...
I’d love to see the city’s media (especially on TV) do something more than parrot the team and mayor’s talking points. I’d love to see this town get actually pissed off about the fact that our glut of tourist tax money can go to hundred-million-dollar venue after hundred-million-dollar venue while our schools are substandard, our city is quantifiably dangerous, and our public transit system is a mess.
I’d love to see us be half as enraged about that as St. Petersburg is about its pier. I’d love to see something other than apathy.
Sunday, August 25, 2013
New Poll: Public Subsidies for Stadium in Tampa Unpopular
A new poll shows that while Tampa Mayor Bob Buckhorn is wildly popular in Tampa, his idea of public dollars going toward a new Rays stadium may not be.
According to SaintPetersblog, 584 randomly-chosen Tampa voters - weighted to account for citywide demographics - said they opposed taxpayer dollars going toward a stadium by a 56%-36% margin. The survey had a 4.1% margin of error and polled all voters; not just likely voters.
A follow-up question asked how voters would prefer to spend the city's $100-$150 million in soon-to-be-available dowtown TIF money. Only 12% of voters chose the stadium option, trailing homeless solutions (31% ), transportation projects (27%), and police/fire (13%). It's a bit of a misleading question, however, since the TIF money is quite limited in how it can be spent and can only go toward Downtown Tampa projects.
Now, I haven't seen the actual poll yet and don't know the exact questions, so its tough to draw conclusions. Especially since - much like you can make statistics say anything you want - you can often determine a poll's outcome by the phrasing of the question.
For example, a series of 2012 polls asked Atlanta residents if they favored tax dollars going toward a new Falcons stadium. About 70% of residents opposed it. But when it was explained the tax dollars were from tourist taxes, which came mostly from out-of-towners, the opposition dropped to almost 50%.
The voter opposition didn't matter in the grand scheme anyway, because Atlanta's city council made the decision to subsidize a stadium without voter approval. But I suspect a few more Tampa voters could be convinced to support a taxpayer-subsidized stadium if the money was coming from tourist or rental car taxes (even though, of course, that money could be used in a host of other ways across the city).
UPDATE - The entire poll is posted here. The exact question was "Do you believe that taxpayer dollars should be used to help pay for a new Tampa Bay Rays baseball stadium in Tampa?"
Interesting: more Republicans favor tax dollars for a Tampa stadium than Democrats. Support for stadium subsidies was stronger among white and younger voters; weaker among black and older voters.
According to SaintPetersblog, 584 randomly-chosen Tampa voters - weighted to account for citywide demographics - said they opposed taxpayer dollars going toward a stadium by a 56%-36% margin. The survey had a 4.1% margin of error and polled all voters; not just likely voters.
A follow-up question asked how voters would prefer to spend the city's $100-$150 million in soon-to-be-available dowtown TIF money. Only 12% of voters chose the stadium option, trailing homeless solutions (31% ), transportation projects (27%), and police/fire (13%). It's a bit of a misleading question, however, since the TIF money is quite limited in how it can be spent and can only go toward Downtown Tampa projects.
Now, I haven't seen the actual poll yet and don't know the exact questions, so its tough to draw conclusions. Especially since - much like you can make statistics say anything you want - you can often determine a poll's outcome by the phrasing of the question.
For example, a series of 2012 polls asked Atlanta residents if they favored tax dollars going toward a new Falcons stadium. About 70% of residents opposed it. But when it was explained the tax dollars were from tourist taxes, which came mostly from out-of-towners, the opposition dropped to almost 50%.
The voter opposition didn't matter in the grand scheme anyway, because Atlanta's city council made the decision to subsidize a stadium without voter approval. But I suspect a few more Tampa voters could be convinced to support a taxpayer-subsidized stadium if the money was coming from tourist or rental car taxes (even though, of course, that money could be used in a host of other ways across the city).
UPDATE - The entire poll is posted here. The exact question was "Do you believe that taxpayer dollars should be used to help pay for a new Tampa Bay Rays baseball stadium in Tampa?"
Interesting: more Republicans favor tax dollars for a Tampa stadium than Democrats. Support for stadium subsidies was stronger among white and younger voters; weaker among black and older voters.
New Week, New Reading Material
A few links for your Sunday reading pleasure:
- Mayor Bob Buckhorn says a Sulpher Springs stadium idea is all well and good, but a new Rays home has to be Downtown Tampa
- The Orlando Magic may get some more subsidies from the City of Orlando...but the Orlando Weekly asks, "Can we please stop pretending the Orlando Magic are doing us a favor?"
- How well can you play the Stadium Naming Rights game?
- Colts owner Jim Irsay tells fans they aren't getting ripped off by having to buy preseason tickets; that's just the price you pay to own season tickets
Saturday, August 24, 2013
UPDATE: Rays Supporters Cast Votes in St. Pete Mayoral Election (with Checkbooks)
Following up an Aug 1 post about Rays-related campaign contributions in the St. Pete mayoral race, candidates just filed their final reports before Tuesday's primary and there are a few interesting contributions for each of the frontrunners:
Mayor Bill Foster:
Mayor Bill Foster:
- $500 from Thomas Sansone, minority owner of the Tampa Bay Rays
- $500 from the St. Pete Chamber PAC, one of Pinellas' pivitol players in the Stadium Saga
- $500 from David Feaster, former president of grass-roots Rays boosters, The Clutch Hitters
- $100 from Dick Greco, former Tampa mayor
- $100 from Bob Byelick, chairman of The Clutch Hitters
- $250 from Harry Cohen, Tampa city councilman
And it should be noted: while the St. Pete mayors race is a non-partisan affair, many contributions tend to fall along party lines, rather than stances on a stadium. Nevertheless, there was little support for candidate Kathleen Ford's campaign from those involved in the stadium debate.
The maximum allowable donation in this race is $500.
The polls close at 7 p.m. Tuesday night, with the top two finishers facing off in November.
The polls close at 7 p.m. Tuesday night, with the top two finishers facing off in November.
St. Pete Chamber Chair Fires Back Across Bay
The chairman of St. Petersburg's Chamber of Commerce, David Punzak, penned a Letter to the Editor in response to Cathy Peek McEwen's Op-Ed earlier this week entitled, "MLB has duty to help free Rays from financial prison."
There was one seemingly glaring factual inaccuracy in the story about Rays ticket-holders, but Punzak was even less impressed:
Could multi-county contributions be in the region's future?
There was one seemingly glaring factual inaccuracy in the story about Rays ticket-holders, but Punzak was even less impressed:
As a 16-year Rays season-ticket holder and the current chairman of the St. Pete Area Chamber of Commerce, I was very disappointed to see the above-referenced article printed in the Tribune. I recognize Cathy Peek McEwen’s column appeared in the Other Views section, so her words are not the position of the newspaper. That is good news.The St. Pete Chamber, which teamed up with the Tampa Area Chamber to research stadium financing last year, hasn't exactly been supportive of a Tampa stadium replacing the Trop. However, it should be encouraging for stadium supporters to hear the suggestion of "economic contribution of people living in all communities in the Tampa Bay area."
The article is close-minded, factually inaccurate and deliberately inciteful. It is the baseball equivalent of race baiting. It was written to include many material inaccuracies, and many regional myths perpetuated by these types of articles.
What disturbs me most about this article is that it dredges up a lot of very bad, decades-old history between the Tampa and St. Pete communities. I thought we were past that. As business leaders, it is our job to move past this unhealthy rhetoric. We’re working hard with our partners and leaders at the Greater Tampa Chamber of Commerce to help reshape the conversation about baseball.
We all need to look forward, not backward.
In order for Major League Baseball to succeed in the Tampa Bay area (whether in St. Petersburg or Tampa), it is going to take the collective goodwill, buy-in and economic contribution of people living in all communities in the Tampa Bay area.
Parochial, mean-spirited views, like those of Ms. McEwen that intentionally malign nearly half of the entire Tampa Bay area community, do nothing to ensure the continued success of MLB in this area.
Could multi-county contributions be in the region's future?
Friday, August 23, 2013
Buccaneers Hire New Lobbyists
According to Saint Petersblog, the Tampa Bay Buccaneers have hired lobbying firm Corcoran and Johnson. The team also retains GrayRobinson and
RSA Consulting as representation.
So while there's no indication what issue(s) the Bucs will be pushing in Tallahassee, it was just a few days ago I wondered out loud when the Rays might hire their own lobbyist.
Maybe they two franchises can team up so the Rays can spend more on players and the Bucs can spend more on locker room cleaning?
So while there's no indication what issue(s) the Bucs will be pushing in Tallahassee, it was just a few days ago I wondered out loud when the Rays might hire their own lobbyist.
Maybe they two franchises can team up so the Rays can spend more on players and the Bucs can spend more on locker room cleaning?
Orlando Soccer Stadium Idea Making Headlines
Public subsidy opponents may not oppose public subsidies as much as you think. It's just that being a watchdog means watching out for the public's investment.
In Orlando, there's great momentum to build an $85 million soccer stadium for a minor-league-but-hopefully-soon-major-league team. But as upwards of $55 million in public money is being discussed for the deal, Orange County commissioner Pete Clarke is suggesting the city secure a share of ownership in the team in exchange for the money.
So rather than just handing the money off to another entity, the city would become an actual investor and actually benefit from the real profit of a stadium generates (ticket sales, stadium revenues, etc).
Now, since Major League Soccer isn't a bunch of individual businesses, but a single business entity (the league owns the teams and the players' contracts), Clarke suggests instead the city guarantee itself a share of new stadium revenues.
Deadspin called it “the best idea for stadium financing I’ve ever heard.”
And Field of Schemes author Neil deMaus sent the following critique to the Orlando Sentinel:
In Orlando, there's great momentum to build an $85 million soccer stadium for a minor-league-but-hopefully-soon-major-league team. But as upwards of $55 million in public money is being discussed for the deal, Orange County commissioner Pete Clarke is suggesting the city secure a share of ownership in the team in exchange for the money.
So rather than just handing the money off to another entity, the city would become an actual investor and actually benefit from the real profit of a stadium generates (ticket sales, stadium revenues, etc).
Now, since Major League Soccer isn't a bunch of individual businesses, but a single business entity (the league owns the teams and the players' contracts), Clarke suggests instead the city guarantee itself a share of new stadium revenues.
Deadspin called it “the best idea for stadium financing I’ve ever heard.”
And Field of Schemes author Neil deMaus sent the following critique to the Orlando Sentinel:
That looks like a great idea. As I’ve always said, the problem with the current stadium business isn’t that the public is putting up money, it’s that the public is putting up money without getting anything back. If Orlando could get an actual share of the stadium revenues – and it’d have to be gross revenues, mind you, not net profits, since it’s too easy for clubs to cook the books with the latter – then this could actually be an investment, and not just a gift.Meanwhile, there are other thoughts coming out of Orlando.....alt weekly Orlando Weekly had some tough words for Bud Selig & MLB in its story titled "Stadiums. Don't. Work."
Here’s an idea: Bring (the Rays) to Orlando. Our local leaders have yet to meet a taxpayer-subsidized sports facility they didn’t love.Needless to say, the story continues to quote numerous economists who have studied stadiums' (lack of) effects...which will obviously still fall on the deaf ears of some of this blog's readers, who I'm sure are anxiously awaiting the opportunity to debunk the evidence with independent economic impact studies of their own...
...
But the economics literature is clear: Taxpayer-subsidized stadiums are losers. Full stop. Anyone who says differently is either lying or woefully misinformed.
...
The economic impact studies teams bandy about – Orlando City (soccer club), for instance, promises a $1.2 billion impact over the next 30 years – are hocus-pocus. They “overstate the contribution that professional sports make to an area’s community. … Specifically, because of sport- and stadium-related activities, other spending declines as people substitute spending on one for spending on the other.”
In the 37 metropolitan areas Coates and Humphreys studied, building a stadium had no discernable impact on the growth rate of real per capita income. Once you factor in the cost of building the stadium, per capita income actually decreases.
Thursday, August 22, 2013
Possible New Stadium Locations: Anywhere There's a City Block & a Cell Phone
I've always said you could poll 100 Rays fans about where they'd like to see a new stadium built, and 100 would agree they'd like one built closer to where they live.
So it should be no huge surprise Hillsborough County Commissioner Victor Crist is floating the idea of a possible stadium in his district, near Sulpher Springs and USF, a little ways up I-275 from Downtown Tampa.
He says the former Tampa Greyhound Track could be an ideal location, with ample land and I-275 exit ramps already built. Crist says it would preserve valuable Downtown Tampa land for other uses, and even speculates the complex could also possibly include a new USF football stadium.
Of course, Hillsborough County doesn't have the money to pay for a new baseball stadium, let alone a football stadium too. And if the stadium isn't built in Downtown Tampa, you can kiss the $100-$150 million in established TIF funds goodbye too. Crist suggests a new TIF could be created in the currently blighted area, but with no track record, those funds would be much tougher to bond.
Tampa Mayor Bob Buckhorn seemed unimpressed, telling the Times: "I don't think anybody has really given it any serious consideration, because the model for Major League Baseball over the last decade has been stadiums in the downtown core...They want a stadium that's walkable."
Remember, location has never been as important in this discussion as financing. And even Buckhorn admitted possible stadium locations are a dime-a-dozen.
"Anybody with a city block and a cell phone is going to try to put their property in play," he said.
So it should be no huge surprise Hillsborough County Commissioner Victor Crist is floating the idea of a possible stadium in his district, near Sulpher Springs and USF, a little ways up I-275 from Downtown Tampa.
He says the former Tampa Greyhound Track could be an ideal location, with ample land and I-275 exit ramps already built. Crist says it would preserve valuable Downtown Tampa land for other uses, and even speculates the complex could also possibly include a new USF football stadium.
Of course, Hillsborough County doesn't have the money to pay for a new baseball stadium, let alone a football stadium too. And if the stadium isn't built in Downtown Tampa, you can kiss the $100-$150 million in established TIF funds goodbye too. Crist suggests a new TIF could be created in the currently blighted area, but with no track record, those funds would be much tougher to bond.
Tampa Mayor Bob Buckhorn seemed unimpressed, telling the Times: "I don't think anybody has really given it any serious consideration, because the model for Major League Baseball over the last decade has been stadiums in the downtown core...They want a stadium that's walkable."
Remember, location has never been as important in this discussion as financing. And even Buckhorn admitted possible stadium locations are a dime-a-dozen.
"Anybody with a city block and a cell phone is going to try to put their property in play," he said.
Wednesday, August 21, 2013
A McEwen Op-Ed on Rays
I often wondered what legendary Tampa sportswriter Tom McEwen thought about the Rays' Stadium Saga - so I interviewed him about a year before his 2011 death. He had an interesting perspective; his old-school mentality approached stadium-building much like a fan approaches his/her favorite team. To Tom, cheerleading a cause like a new stadium was justified because of its benefit to the community.
Today, McEwen's former daughter-in-law and Trib sportswriter, Cathy Peek McEwen, penned an op-ed in her former paper calling on MLB to step in and fix its broken system in Tampa Bay:
Except the one flaw in the argument is that St. Pete's residents have paid millions of dollars the last few decades for the right to have a baseball team. And MLB, Vince Naimoli, and Stu Sternberg all agreed to a contract promising baseball to St. Petersburg until 2027.
Promises may be meant to be broken, but contracts can be a stickier subject...
Today, McEwen's former daughter-in-law and Trib sportswriter, Cathy Peek McEwen, penned an op-ed in her former paper calling on MLB to step in and fix its broken system in Tampa Bay:
Simply put, MLB is as much to blame, maybe more, on the Rays’ poor attendance as St. Petersburg and Pinellas County (which lag behind Tampa in providing behinds in seats, interestingly). Accordingly, MLB itself needs to atone for the sins of the owners who voted to imprison a franchise in a place their commissioner recognized could not be a major league town.But McEwen also blamed St. Pete Mayor Foster for "trying to reinvent history" and claim his city needs to be compensated for what its owed on its investment. Her contention is that St. Pete built the Trop without a baseball team and its not owed a baseball team now.
...
Agree to fund a meaningful share of a new stadium in a central location, one that can be easily reached by a critical mass of fans. That critical mass together with the Rays’ talented owners and local governments that value keeping MLB in the central Gulf Coast area will do the rest.
Except the one flaw in the argument is that St. Pete's residents have paid millions of dollars the last few decades for the right to have a baseball team. And MLB, Vince Naimoli, and Stu Sternberg all agreed to a contract promising baseball to St. Petersburg until 2027.
Promises may be meant to be broken, but contracts can be a stickier subject...
You Can Make an Economic Impact Report Say Anything
The Rays bring $200+ million a year to Tampa Bay. According to the Tampa Bay Rays.
The funny thing about economic impact reports is you can make them say anything you want.
When the Rays wanted to justify a new stadium in 2008, they commissioned a study that validated their nine-figure annual economic impact. There has been some good journalism since then questioning the methodology of the Rays' study; the Times' Stephen Nohlgren pointed out spending on a baseball game is often transferred spending from other areas of the economy, not new spending.
Even the pro-baseball ABC Coalition acknowledged "economic impact studies are often overblown."
But those kind of important questions and disclosures were missing yesterday when the City of Tampa and RNC 2012 Host Committee announced its $400 million economic impact last August for the Republican National Convention.
Both the Tampa Tribune and Tampa Bay Times ran glowing reviews, and even though the stories pointed out retail, restaurants, and bars all lost out during convention time, there was little questioning the report's methodology.
Now, I'm no economist, but it was easy to see the report was using robust sales tax receipts from outlying counties (Polk, Pasco, Manatee) to make up for slow sales numbers in the convention's host county, Hillsborough.
In fact, if sales tax numbers compared to the rest of the state indicate how the RNC affected a local economy, we should blame the RNC for Hillsborough County's bad August sales tax receipts, which grew much slower than the state's average.
And I'm not sure how any economist can claim - at least with a straight face - that a boost in spending at places like LEGOLAND (Polk Co) or Weeki Watchee (Hernando Co) had anything to do with the RNC.
One thing is clear: Tampa did a nice job hosting the event and for an up-and-coming city, the convention was a great resume-builder. But the beautiful thing about claiming $100+ million in media impressions and other intangibles is that you can claim them and there's no tangible evidence to disprove them.
"With all my effort I have looked for evidence of any kind of economic impact from a Super Bowl or the RNC and never found any," USF economist Philip Porter told me in an e-mail. "In terms of what people in Tampa sell, including their labor, events (like the RNC) have no impact."
Don't expect Porter to land any economic impact studies anytime soon.
Nor will Field of Schemes author Neil deMause, who wrote about a pro-Oakland Athletics study back in 2010:
The funny thing about economic impact reports is you can make them say anything you want.
When the Rays wanted to justify a new stadium in 2008, they commissioned a study that validated their nine-figure annual economic impact. There has been some good journalism since then questioning the methodology of the Rays' study; the Times' Stephen Nohlgren pointed out spending on a baseball game is often transferred spending from other areas of the economy, not new spending.
Even the pro-baseball ABC Coalition acknowledged "economic impact studies are often overblown."
But those kind of important questions and disclosures were missing yesterday when the City of Tampa and RNC 2012 Host Committee announced its $400 million economic impact last August for the Republican National Convention.
Now, I'm no economist, but it was easy to see the report was using robust sales tax receipts from outlying counties (Polk, Pasco, Manatee) to make up for slow sales numbers in the convention's host county, Hillsborough.
In fact, if sales tax numbers compared to the rest of the state indicate how the RNC affected a local economy, we should blame the RNC for Hillsborough County's bad August sales tax receipts, which grew much slower than the state's average.
And I'm not sure how any economist can claim - at least with a straight face - that a boost in spending at places like LEGOLAND (Polk Co) or Weeki Watchee (Hernando Co) had anything to do with the RNC.
One thing is clear: Tampa did a nice job hosting the event and for an up-and-coming city, the convention was a great resume-builder. But the beautiful thing about claiming $100+ million in media impressions and other intangibles is that you can claim them and there's no tangible evidence to disprove them.
"With all my effort I have looked for evidence of any kind of economic impact from a Super Bowl or the RNC and never found any," USF economist Philip Porter told me in an e-mail. "In terms of what people in Tampa sell, including their labor, events (like the RNC) have no impact."
Don't expect Porter to land any economic impact studies anytime soon.
Nor will Field of Schemes author Neil deMause, who wrote about a pro-Oakland Athletics study back in 2010:
Ah, "economic activity," the last refuge of the economic development consultant. As I've discussed here previously, this just adds up all the money changing hands in your city, regardless of who's spending it and who's receiving it — so that if the A's double ticket prices, that's not a horrible ripoff of Oakland fans, but rather a wonderful boost to "economic activity," notwithstanding that the people actually receiving the bulk of the cash (the A's owners and players) don't live in town.Journalists live by the motto "question everything." And the more we ask about these studies, the better-informed we'll be the next time we have to make decisions about which events and institutions to spend money on.
Tuesday, August 20, 2013
Forbes: Bucs' Franchise Valuation Ticks Upward
The latest Forbes valuations are out, and while they may not be worth the paper they're (not) printed on, the Glazer family can celebrate the fact that the Bucs' estimated franchise value is up to $1.07 billion, a 3.5% increase from last fall.
That's pennies to a family worth $4.4 billion, but the uptick in value is impressive given the fact that the Glazers continue to let blackouts tarnish the experience for fans in Tampa Bay.
The league's most expensive team was once again the Cowboys, who surged from $2.1 billion last year to $2.3 billion this year, courtesy of a new half-billion-dollar stadium naming rights deal.
But as Cork Gaines points out, the NFL's rise in franchise values (currently averaging $1.17 billion) aren't growing nearly as high as MLB franchises' (currently averaging $744 million).
That's pennies to a family worth $4.4 billion, but the uptick in value is impressive given the fact that the Glazers continue to let blackouts tarnish the experience for fans in Tampa Bay.
The league's most expensive team was once again the Cowboys, who surged from $2.1 billion last year to $2.3 billion this year, courtesy of a new half-billion-dollar stadium naming rights deal.
But as Cork Gaines points out, the NFL's rise in franchise values (currently averaging $1.17 billion) aren't growing nearly as high as MLB franchises' (currently averaging $744 million).
Why Haven't the Rays Hired a Lobbyist Yet?
Just thinking out loud here, but sooner or later, the Rays will probably need to hire a lobbyist governmental relations expert.
Hillsborough County's biggest pot of money possibly available for a new stadium would be in new rental car taxes, which tend to be easy pills to swallow politically, because they put most of the burden on out-of-towners (even if those visitors have no clue the region has a MLB team).
However, new rental car taxes at Tampa International Airport are currently illegal. So the Rays would need help from the legislature. Which typically requires a little lobbying firepower.
Not to mention, the team could use some help with another legal issue its having with the state.
MLB teams hiring lobbyists is hardly unheard of; several have succeeded in the legislative sausage factory by hiring "governmental relations experts."
So how long before the Rays hire theirs? We'll have some sort of an idea; professional lobbyists in Florida need to register with the state.
Hillsborough County's biggest pot of money possibly available for a new stadium would be in new rental car taxes, which tend to be easy pills to swallow politically, because they put most of the burden on out-of-towners (even if those visitors have no clue the region has a MLB team).
However, new rental car taxes at Tampa International Airport are currently illegal. So the Rays would need help from the legislature. Which typically requires a little lobbying firepower.
Not to mention, the team could use some help with another legal issue its having with the state.
MLB teams hiring lobbyists is hardly unheard of; several have succeeded in the legislative sausage factory by hiring "governmental relations experts."
So how long before the Rays hire theirs? We'll have some sort of an idea; professional lobbyists in Florida need to register with the state.
Report: Rays May Lose Billboard
You can't blame the Rays for trying to maximize every revenue opportunity they have, but apparently the State of Florida does.
According to the Tampa Tribune, the team's 34-by-64 sign above I-275 was never permitted as a billboard. While businesses are allowed to advertise their own events, the Rays sell space on theirs to other companies, which would required billboard permitting. And because its too close to other billboards, the Trib reports the team's permit is likely to be turned down:
According to the Tampa Tribune, the team's 34-by-64 sign above I-275 was never permitted as a billboard. While businesses are allowed to advertise their own events, the Rays sell space on theirs to other companies, which would required billboard permitting. And because its too close to other billboards, the Trib reports the team's permit is likely to be turned down:
The Rays wouldn't comment to the Trib on how much revenue the sign produced.But state officials warn that is likely to be turned down because the Rays' sign is closer than 1,500 feet to another permitted billboard, the minimum distance state regulations allow between signs.
“There would be a spacing conflict with another permitted sign,” said Rob Jessee, FDOT manager of outdoor advertising control. “It predates their sign and would cause a spacing conflict along the interstate.”
That may leave the Rays with a dent in their revenue.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)