Tuesday, September 10, 2013

Tampa Port Authority Tries to Takeover Channelside Bay Plaza

The morass at Downtown Tampa's Channelside Bay Plaza appears to be coming to an end, as the Port of Tampa has come to an agreement to buy the struggling retail center for $5.75 million.

Lightning owner Jeff Vinik appears to be the frontrunner to now buy and rehab the plaza, but Tampa Mayor Bob Buckhorn - a member of the Port's board of directors - indicated the property will go out for bids since so many tax dollars will be at stake.

But since Buckhorn loves talking baseball, we can also count on lots of Rays-to-Channelside rumors the next few days.
But this news doesn't change much about the Stadium Saga - at least in the short-term. Finding a place for the Rays to play has never been a problem...it's all about finding the money to build a new stadium.

And as for whether Jeff Vinik decides to sell his stake in the Boston Red Sox and get involved in Rays stadium-building or just focus on bolstering Downtown Tampa's entertainment district....is a question for way down the road.

In other news, exhibition baseball is returning to Montreal next spring, giving us hundreds of additional headlines to look forward to next year about how the Rays are candidates to move to Canada.

Monday, September 9, 2013

Sportstalk Station Launches "Save Tampa Bay Baseball" Campaign

Tampa Bay's 98.7 The Fan radio announced today is is launching the Save Tampa Bay Baseball campaign.  I'm not quite sure what it needs saving from...Bud Selig's boogeyman?

According to its press release, 98.7 The Fan is launching a "multi-tiered campaign to help keep the hometown Tampa Bay Rays baseball team in the region."

But it's website says, "It's unfathomable to think that Tampa Bay may soon be without a major league baseball team, but it's a VERY real possibility - and one we won't accept."  

Did Bud Selig write this himself?

The rest of its press release is below:
98.7 The Fan has launched www.SaveTampaBayBaseball.com to raise awareness that the Rays may be in danger of leaving Tampa Bay, as well as a petition drive to let Major League Baseball know that the Rays belong in Tampa Bay. As the local business community has been a great ally of the Tampa Bay Rays, the 98.7 The Fan Street Team will canvass the downtown area offering Save Tampa Bay Baseball window stickers to all local merchants who support the Rays.
 
In addition, 98.7 The Fan will host an official Save Tampa Bay Baseball Rally on September 12 at Ferg’s Sports Bar & Grill – home of the 98.7 The Fan “Fan Cave” – before the Rays vs. Boston Red Sox game.
 
“At 98.7 The Fan, we strongly believe it’s in the best interest of the Tampa Bay community to keep Major League Baseball here,” said John O’Connell, Program Director for 98.7 The Fan. “We will support our hometown Rays every way we can, and encourage Rays fans and the Tampa/St. Petersburg community to join us.”
The "Save Tampa Bay Baseball" rally takes place this Thursday, 3 p.m. to 7 p.m., at Ferg's in St. Pete.

Sunday, September 8, 2013

Update: Tampa Bay Times Editorial Board Still Hates Bill Foster

Sunday morning's Tampa Bay Times featured another editorial attacking Mayor Bill Foster's handling of the Stadium Saga; specifically, his memo criticizing MLB Commissioner Bud Selig for interfering with negotiations between the city and the Rays:
St. Petersburg Mayor Bill Foster wants to blame baseball commissioner Bud Selig for his own failures. Selig is hardly a sympathetic character, but he's not the reason stadium negotiations between the city and the Tampa Bay Rays are stalled. The reason is Foster's lack of leadership and poor negotiating skills, and the stalemate is more evidence that St. Petersburg needs a new mayor.
The Times suggests any recent progress is a result of Foster's political opportunism (well, every issue in an election year is political).  And any lack of progress is a result of Foster's lack of leadership.

But do the Times' editorial-writers have any idea what's happening in the closed-door negotiations between St. Pete and the Rays?

Do they really not care that the league and team are reportedly refusing to consider any compensation for breaking St. Pete's contract early?  Do they really not care the Rays have yet to even indicate support for the presumed starting point for negotiations - the proposed "Pay-to-Stray" amendment put forward by councilman Charlie Gerdes?

The editorial may not think Selig is a sympathetic character, but it seems to have a lot of sympathy for him:
What prompted Foster's abrupt outburst last week that indicated talks have broken down? It should not have been Selig's recent complaints about the pace of the negotiations. The baseball commissioner naturally is interested in the economics of baseball revenue sharing and doesn't want the less profitable franchises to keep being propped up by the others.
At least the Times recognizes the Rays are profitable and MLB's M.O. is to increase its $8 billion/yr revenue numbers.  And a new stadium would merely reduce how much money teams like the Red Sox and Yankees ship to Tampa Bay.
It also would be no surprise if the private talks broke down because Foster overplayed his hand. This mayor does not have a good reputation for negotiating in good faith and finding reasonable middle ground, whether it's with the Rays over the stadium, or Pinellas County over the EMS system, or the city of Tampa over bills for the Republican National Convention.

(Mayoral challenger Rick) Kriseman pledges to negotiate with the Rays on allowing the team to look at stadium sites in Tampa. His suggestion that the Rays lower ticket prices in return is intriguing. But there are bigger issues to consider: How much would the Rays pay toward demolishing Tropicana Field? How would they help the city prepare the site for redevelopment? How much would they pay the city to leave for a new stadium in Tampa before the Trop lease expired?
So practically in the same breath the editorial board criticizes Foster for being stubborn in negotiations, it calls upon the Rays to answer questions they've not shown any willingness to publicly address yet.  Questions from elected leaders and media alike get frequent "no comment" responses from the Rays.

But once again, the Times casts Foster as its foil.  And once again, the Rays get a free pass from the paper.

Just a small sampling of other Times editorials ripping Foster's handling of the Stadium Saga in the last couple of years:
Feb 2013  |  Feb 2013
Jan 2013  |  Jan 2013
Oct 2012  |  April 2012

Saturday, September 7, 2013

Fallout From Foster's Memo: Day 2

On one hand, you have to give Hillsborough Commission Chair Ken Hagan credit for being forward-thinking.  The land and financing and politics of the Stadium Saga are unlikely to come together all at once, so preserving all options is a good idea.

But on the other hand, is it really necessary to convince one of Downtown Tampa's brightest minds - Jeff Vinik - that he shouldn't close the door on a possible Downtown Tampa baseball stadium?

In this morning's Tampa Tribune:
Hillsborough County Commission Chairman Ken Hagan has asked the owner of the Tampa Bay Lightning hockey team, Jeff Vinik, to consider a Rays stadium on land he partly owns across from the Forum in downtown Tampa. Vinik is a partner with a Colorado-based investment group in at least 14 acres across from the Forum, and he’s been planning a large-scale development project there.

Hagan said he asked Vinik’s group not to make any plans until the Rays’ standoff with St. Petersburg is resolved. Hagan said he’s not committed to Vinik’s property, which sits on each side of Caesar Street and just north of Channelside Drive, but wants to have several potential stadium sites available in case the Rays come knocking.
One thing is certain: Vinik, who is a minority owner of the Boston Red Sox, needs no reminding about the possible uses for his land.

But the stalemate between St. Pete and the Rays could very well linger for years.  And if Downtown Tampa really needs a baseball stadium to trigger development, there won't be any major projects filling the Channelside area anytime soon anyway.  However, if developers are clamoring to fill all those downtown parcels right now and people are clamoring to move there, would a baseball stadium (likely land not on tax rolls) really be the highest-and-best use of that land?

“What I have asked (Vinik's group) to do is to not make any commitments toward their development until we have an understanding of how the Rays’ potential relocation efforts are played out,” Hagan told the Trib.

There's a lot of value in creating a master plan for downtown, but if Vinik and other developers were really on the verge of doing something with all that vacant land, the suggestion of slowing that progress could be counter-productive.

Hagan, who once said he didn't support any public money going toward a stadium, also told the Trib he was opposed to Hillsborough County compensating St. Pete for the early termination of their Rays contract.

“No, I can’t see any circumstance where Hillsborough County would compensate St. Pete for allowing the Rays to break their use agreement,” he said.

While Hillsborough may never actually cut St. Pete a check, if it costs anything to "make St. Pete whole," it's simply increasing the bottom line cost of a new stadium, which Tampa/Hillsborough taxpayers would presumably help subsidize.

However, if Hagan is siding with Bud Selig in the alleged MLB/St. Pete brouhaha over compensation, it's only playing into the Rays' hand and making the current impasse harder to solve.

Thursday, September 5, 2013

Fallout from Foster's Memo: Day 1

Predictably, the Times headline this morning, "Mayor: Talks going badly," created a lot of other headlines today...even though the mayor never actually said talks were going badly.

However, councilmembers were telling the Tampa Tribune that's exactly what's going on: the Rays are refusing to compensate St. Pete for leaving Tropicana Field early:
“Their premise is they shouldn't have to pay us anything,” (council chair Karl Nurse) said. “I can't imagine how they can say, 'We owe you nothing. Goodbye.' And I can't imagine the city agreeing to that.”
Mayor Foster said negotiations were going well until Bud Selig's August 15 comments, but now no further meetings are scheduled.

These compensation disagreements - if they are true - are part of the unsurprising tug-of-war over public opinion and negotiating leverage.  Two years ago, Shadow of the Stadium wrote, "What Bill Foster is Thinking" and it still rings true today:
It comes to down to preserving St. Pete’s equity in Major League Baseball. The city agreed to build a stadium in exchange for 30 years of baseball. Foster sees anything short of that benchmark unacceptable.

Is he willing to negotiate? Sure. Is he willing to accept financial restitution in exchange for early termination of the contract? Probably. But that hasn't been offered by the Rays.

What has been offered is a region-wide search for a better location and Foster already knows what that would yeild: a Tampa vs. St. Pete tug-of-war. When the
Tribune suggests a Tampa stadium plan would do nothing to interfere with St. Pete's relationship, they're wrong. It takes away St. Pete's leverage.

And in a stalemate that will ultimately come down to a negotiation over hundreds of millions of dollars in public subsidies, Foster the Lawyer can't afford to lose any leverage.
Just like a homeowner, St. Pete has a right to look out for the equity it has built in this contract; those are taxpayers' dollars.

And if you disagree, ask yourself these questions:
  1. If you buy a home and finish paying off your 30-year mortgage early, is your equity zero just because you have finished the debt service? Or do you still have the right to the equity you originally bargained for?
  2. If Evan Longoria decides he deserves a better contract, does he have the right to walk away from his current deal without penalty?
  3. If the Rays claim they're bringing value to Tampa, doesn't it suggest they're taking it away from St. Pete?

Meanwhile, sportstalk radio was all abuzz with Rays talk Thursday and I spent a good 15 minutes chatting with WDAE's Steve Duemig (you can listen to it here).  But one thing he asked was if Mayor Foster's public foray was "politicking."  My response: "of course!"

The political ramifications of any major news two months before a major election are always calculated.  And the Times was quick to recap the "campaign rhetoric" fallout.

"I don't lie," mayoral challenger Rick Kriseman told the Times. "You can trust me...We will have honest dialogue."

But Foster fired back, telling the Times, "There is a big difference between politics and governing...I'd appreciate it if he'd leave the governing to me. I'm not going to play politics with taxpayers' money."

When asked what he'd do different, Kriseman said he'd push mass transit (which Foster has supported as well) and propose the Rays pay for the right to look in Tampa with a different kind of concession:
Rather than charge the team a fee for exploring sites outside the city, he would grant permission in exchange for them lowering ticket prices next season to lure more fans. He also wants to create incentive programs with restaurants and hotels to make games attractive to tourists and visitors.
The Rays declined to comment on the ideas and Foster then called them "naive":
"I have been working with the organization for two years to make sure taxpayers interests are preserved and recognized," (Foster) said. "It sounds like a Kriseman administration would give everything away."
UPDATE: Kriseman's campaign manager, Cesar Fernandez, later told me the Times got Kriseman's concept wrong and the proposal was not "one season of cheap tickets in exchange for the right to look" - it was merely brainstorming. 

Given all of the politicking between the mayoral candidates, there was a stark contrast from city council this week, as I first pointed out this morning.

My WTSP colleague Preston Rudie spoke with councilmember Charlie Gerdes, who authored the unsuccessful amendment to allow the Rays to look in Tampa, and his message was that MLB should just butt out at this point.

As for Tampa Mayor Bob Buckhorn, he told Rudie that baseball just won't work in St. Pete, but he's still stuck on the sidelines until the Rays and St. Pete finalize their "divorce" and give Tampa their blessing to start talking.

How Bud Selig Could Get a New Stadium Deal Done Today

Saw this gem on Twitter today:
That salary is more than the entire Downtown Tampa TIF generates in bondable real estate taxes.  And since Mayor Buckhorn explained those revenues can be bonded at a 10-to-1 rate over 30 years (Field of Schemes' Neil deMause says the rate is even higher), Selig could conceivably bond $200 million on his salary alone.

$200 million!?!?!  That's probably enough to close the giant gap that's prohibited the Rays' Stadium Saga from moving forward!

Now, now, I recognize Selig isn't going to remain commissioner for 30 more years and no bank would give him a $200 million personal bond.  But then again, would it be that hard for the league to commit $18M a year to a new Rays stadium?

READ: Bill Foster's Rays Memo to City Council

Upon further examination, it seems St. Pete Mayor Bill Foster's memo to St. Petersburg City Council doesn't actually mention negotiations with the Rays have broken down.  It's more of a public rebuttal to Bud Selig's recent comments:
To: The Honorable Karl Nurse, Chair, and Members of City Council
From: Bill Foster, Mayor
Date: September 4, 2013
Subject: Rays Status Update

In light of recent media reports pertaining to my conversations with the Rays, and the potential intervention by the Commissioner of Baseball, this memorandum will serve to update Council on the status of these discussions.

I am now, and always have been, committed to three things when it comes to the Rays: protecting the public's significant financial investment in bringing Major League Baseball to St. Petersburg, preserving the integrity of the City's bargained for contract with the Rays, and supporting the team. But rather than focus exclusively on the Rays' contractual commitment to play their home games at Tropicana Field through the 2027 season, I began to explore potential avenues of keeping the Rays in the Tampa Bay region for generations to come. With that long term goal in mind, I opened the lines of communication with Mr. Sternberg and the Rays organization to consider options that would allow the Rays to search for future stadium sites in Pinellas and Hillsborough counties, while at the same time protecting the public's financial investment and the City's contractual rights. Both the City and Rays embarked upon these discussions in good faith, with open minds and an eye toward compromise. Over the last several months, we have engaged in hours of telephone conversations and met on numerous occasions. In fact, I believe our last meeting with the Rays, which was only days before the August 15, 2013 Major League Baseball owner's meeting at which Commissioner Selig threatened that Major League Baseball may "intervene", was our most productive to date.

It has become apparent to me that Major League Baseball has no intention of assisting the City and Rays in reaching a mutually beneficial solution. Nor does Major League Baseball seem interested in a cooperative effort to keep the Rays in the Tampa Bay region for the long term. Major League Baseball's sole motivation, and consequently Commissioner Selig's only measure of success in this matter, appears to be accomplishing Major League Baseball's agenda. Major League Baseball's failure to consider all of the parties' interests, not just the interests of Major League Baseball and team owners who contribute to revenue sharing, is the real impediment to progress.

While I remain willing to continue discussions with the Rays and Major League Baseball to attempt to identify an outcome that is equitable to all parties and keeps the team in the Tampa Bay region for generations, I cannot and will not support an outcome that is primarily at the public's expense. Rather than being a hindrance, Major League Baseball can become part of the solution if Commissioner Selig acknowledges that the public's investment in bringing Major League Baseball to St. Petersburg and the contractual commitments made by the Rays cannot be cast aside as trivial and undeserving of any consideration. If Major League Baseball would start to recognize the public's investment in baseball and the Rays' contractual commitments to the City as having even a fraction of the value of a team's investment in a star player and the player's corresponding contractual commitment to his team, I believe we could make real progress that benefits the entire Tampa Bay region.

We will continue our discussions with the Rays, and regardless of what transpires off the field, I encourage everyone to focus our attention on the field by rallying to support our home team. Go Rays!

cc: John Wolfe
Tish Elston

Report: Negotiations Between St. Pete, Rays Breaking Down

It appears Tampa Bay was so excited about the possibility of a new Rays stadium on the other side of the bay, fans ignored the underlying warnings that the team and St. Petersburg were still "a long way off" in negotations.

Mark Puente reports in today's Tampa Bay Times that negotiations between the Rays and St. Pete are "going badly" and Mayor Bill Foster penned a letter to city council indicating MLB may be all-but-sabotaging progress in the region:
"It has become apparent to me that Major League Baseball has no intention of assisting the city and Rays in reaching a mutually beneficial solution," Foster wrote in a memo to the council. "Nor does Major League Baseball seem interested in a cooperative effort to keep the Rays in the Tampa Bay Region for the long term." 
Foster told council members he is committed to more talks but "cannot and will not support an outcome that is primarily at the public's expense."

Sticking points seem to center around how much the team would pay the city for leaving early and to demolish Tropicana Field.
This echoes a Shadow of the Stadium warning from Aug 16:
Clearly, the Rays and St. Pete haven't found common ground yet on the ground rules of a search: either the financial terms or the legal limitations, designed to protect St. Pete's contractual interests.
It's no surprise these high-stakes negotiations public: the city wants to maximize its compensation while the Rays want to diminish the city's financial leverage. 

But the Rays didn't seem happy about the seemingly broken handshake promise not to negotiate through the court of public opinion, issuing a statement calling Foster's memo "unfortunate and unproductive in so many ways."

Foster piled it on MLB Commissioner Bud Selig, saying revenue sharing was his "sole motivation" and the league's failure to consider taxpayers' investment "is the real impediment to progress."  As this blog has pointed out, a new Tampa Bay stadium could mean more to the league's richest teams than it does to the Rays.

Also interesting: some of Foster's typical critics on city council were not-so-quick to pounce on this political opportunity.

Councilman Charlie Gerdes, who authored the first failed amendment to allow the Rays to look in Tampa, told the Times "he doubts Foster is allowing politics to seep into the talks."  And Councilwoman Leslie Curran suggested revisiting talks after the season, adding "there is no love lost between the Rays, the city and Bud Selig."

Tuesday, September 3, 2013

Dissecting the Red Sox' Attendance Drop

Since the Red Sox aren't about to go blaming an outdated ballpark for attendance, there are many questions just why the first-place team's attendance has slipped so much from last year, despite better performance.

Masslive.com reports ticket sales will be down about 7% for the Sox this year, although the team expected it.

The Boston Globe points out the buzz around the team has subsided from it's peak a few years ago.

And the Biz of Baseball concludes ticket sales jumps and drops are often delayed by a year...which means good things to the Sox next year...and bad for teams like the Angels and Giants.

St. Pete Rock n' Roll Half Marathon Canceled

The St. Pete Rock n' Roll Half Marathon, whose economic benefit claims Shadow of the Stadium first questioned early in 2012, has posted a message on its website that it was cancelling next February's race.

In 2012, the inagural race failed to live up to its promise of 12,000-15,000 participants, but organizers said it was because the event was new.  In 2013, the numbers were even worse.

The race organizer, the Competitor Group, will still operate the November St. Pete Women's Half Marathon, which it purchased last year from a local company.

Sunday, September 1, 2013

Tampa Bids on Super Bowl - What Can We Expect?

The Tampa Sports Authority has once again bid on a Super Bowl, hoping to bring the game back to Raymond James Stadium in 2018. Couple the success has Tampa has enjoyed in hosting the Super Bowl with its repeat runner-up status in bidding for the game, and Tampa Bay is probably due to win a bid.

However, the NFL has used Super Bowls (much like MLB has done with All-Star Games) as a carrot to dangle in its stadium-building campaigns. And as the Tampa Bay Times' Drew Harwell writes, 14-year-old Raymond James Stadium will face stiff competition:
Eight newer stadiums have yet to field a Super Bowl, though nearly all are in northern climates typically cold for the late-winter game. The game next February in New Jersey's MetLife Stadium will be the first Super Bowl held in an outdoor northern stadium.
Tampa's Super Bowl bid is secretive, but it most likely included a bevy of incentives and kickbacks for the NFL. That's just the norm these days as competition between cities often negates some of the benefits the Super Bowl is supposed to bring.

In fact, the league is in such a position of power over bidding cities, NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell told Houston officials - after they built the new Reliant Stadium for the Texans - they should spend another $29 million to demolish the adjacent Astrodome to create 2,500 parking spots.

KHOU-TV reported Goodell called demolition a "game changer" in Houston's bid. Then the commish cranked up the pressure, saying, "That issue is for the community to decide, but I think having an extra 2,500 parking spaces would enhance Houston’s bid."

Houston officials actually refused to cave in to the pressure at the time and decided against blowing up the Astrodome. So how integral was that new parking to Houston's bid? They landed the 2017 Super Bowl anyway.

Friday, August 30, 2013

Fact-Checking Rays' Revenue Sharing Campaign

After a quick chat with Field of Schemes' Neil deMause this week, it seems we both came to the conclusion that some of the MLB criticisms heard at this week's Stu Sternberg/Matt Silverman/Tampa Bay Partnership discussions may be off-base.

According to the Tampa Bay Times, prominent businessman and Tampa Bay Partnership chair Chuck Sykes said Sternberg and Silverman reiterated MLB's growing frustrations with how much money they have to share with the Rays:
Sykes said it was interesting to hear that the Seattle Mariners and Cleveland Indians used to be recipients of revenue-sharing, "then over time, as they worked with their various initiatives and new stadiums, they're now a payer into the system."
That was news to our ears, and deMause wrote this morning:
According to Forbes, as of two years ago the Indians were recipients of the biggest revenue-sharing check in baseball; and since then, the team’s attendance has actually gone down. And even if somehow they’ve made a miraculous turnaround since then, it’s hard to see how this can be credited to a stadium that opened in 1994.

It looks like this is going to be the Rays’ PR strategy, though: Yeah, we’re winning ballgames, and making money, but we’re doing it with the help of this revenue-sharing program that MLB specifically set up to help low-revenue teams win ballgames and make money, and there’s no way they’re going to let that continue. To which the sensible response would be: What, so MLB thinks the Rays wouldn’t be revenue-sharing recipients if it moved them to Charlotte or something? But then, sensible responses aren’t the game that MLB is playing — nor, it would seem, is the Tampa Bay Times.
Those comments came within minutes after I posted my dissection of what seems to be MLB's silly revenue-sharing argument.  But at the very least, its comforting to know I'm not the only one who thinks the Rays' campaign to reduce Yankees/Red Sox revenue sharing isn't terribly convincing. 

After all, even if the Rays climbed out of the bottom-10 in revenue, another team would simply take its place and we'd still have the 10 richest teams cutting checks to the 10 poorest teams to preserve some semblance of parity...

Crazy Simplistic Thoughts on the Stadium Saga & a Foolish Revenue Sharing Argument

Some simplistic thoughts following this week's private Stu Sternberg & Matt Silverman chat with local business leaders:
  • Everyone seems to acknowledge MLB's problem with Tampa Bay is that the Rays are sucking a lot of money out of the revenue sharing system.  In fact, Tampa business leader Chuck Sykes even confirmed to the Tampa Bay Times that was the key takeaway from Sternberg/Silverman.
  • So MLB teams such as the Red Sox, Yankees, and Dodgers are upset they have to pool together some of their enormous profits to keep teams like the Tampa Bay Rays (and Pittsburgh Pirates, Oakland A's, etc) competitive on the field.  Of course, the uber-rich NFL shares way more revenue between teams, but I digress....
  • Let's not forget MLB created this revenue-sharing system because it was making so much money in big markets that it needed a way to preserve some sort of competitive balance (because it refused to enact a salary cap).
  • And because the Red Sox, Yankees, and Dodgers want to send less money to the Rays, they are pressuing Bud Selig to expedite the new stadium process in Tampa Bay.
  • Meanwhile, MLB & the Rays don't want to pay for the majority of a new stadium itself, because that wouldn't increase their revenues.
  • Therefore, MLB's "intervening" means pressuring the local community to tear up (or at least alter) it's existing contract with the Rays and spend public funds to build a new stadium so MLB can profit more.
  • In exchange for St. Petersburg agreeing to tear up its current contract with the team/league (I doubt that would ever happen if Evan Longoria decides he doesn't like his contract), MLB promises Tampa Bay that it will receive indirect financial benefits, like a rejuvenated downtown (even though Downtown Tampa is thriving regardless right now).
  • So Tampa Bay municipalities would spend between $25-35 million a year in public subsidies for a new stadium.  And this would - in theory - increase revenues at a stadium by $10-15 million a year.
  • Of course, those revenues don't really allow the Rays to spend more on players; they simply reduce the amount of revenue sharing the team receives from the Red Sox, Yankees, Dodgers, etc.
So in summary, we are talking about spending $25-35 million a year in public subsidies to help the Red Sox, Yankees, and Dodgers pocket an extra $10-15 million a year.  And, of course end the threats from MLB for another 20 years (hopefully)....

Sure, Tampa could enjoy some new additional benefits Downtown if the project is done right in the perfect location...but this line of thinking should also beg the question: how much public help is really worth it?

Given these numbers, there's also the question of whether Tampa Bay would just be better off cutting the Rays a check for $10-15 million a year for the next 20 years, which they could just direct sign over to the Red Sox, Yankees, and Dodgers.  At least that would satisfy MLB into not threatening relocation or contraction for a decade or two....

Thursday, August 29, 2013

Referendum Questions: From St. Pete to Sacramento to Tampa

With the referednum on continuing to build a new St. Pete Pier going down in flames this week, the topic of referendums seems to be coming up quite a bit.

And, depending whom you ask - especially given the pier problems - voters may not always know best.  In fact, there are probably at least a few Rays fans who wish there would have been more support for the canceled "sailboat" stadium referendum in 2008.

But there's an interesting take from the New Ballpark blog on the importance of putting stadium subsidies to a vote:
  1. Public money for stadia in the form of cash, loans, or bonds – whether or not secured by upfront taxes or fees – should never happen in this day and age.
  2. All new or renovated venues that do not require public money are generally good, as long as they don’t come with significant kickbacks for the team and developers.
  3. Any public assistance that goes beyond processing permits or planning work (providing land, money, or other benefits) should require a public vote over the terms of the deal.
New Ballpark is especially critical of the Sacramento arena efforts, which are intentionally avoiding a voter referendum - presumably for the same reason the Rays yanked theirs off the table in 2008 - because true democracy doesn't always produce what elected officials consider the best results.

The post continues:
Are these people nuts? Have some respect for your citizens, politicians. Allow for campaigns. Allow the citizens and fans to be fully educated on the issues. You owe them that much. Sure, campaigns are expensive. The billionaires and millionaires who want these projects can afford campaign costs, they’ve seen and done it before. Chances are that they’ll outspend opponents 10:1. They have the resources. That’s fine. That’s the way the process works.
Eventually, we may see the process repeat itself in Tampa Bay....where a recent poll shows voters have no interest in approving a taxpayer-subsidized stadium.

And a Letter to the Editor in this morning's Times (3rd one down) echoes the sentiment of many residents here, it seems:
We are paying enough for problems from the past -- reservoirs under repair, nuclear energy plants that will never be built, a section of an expressway under construction, and now a section of road just three years old leading to Tampa International Airport...We must learn from our many mistakes. Any plans to build a new baseball stadium must not include any citizen funding and must be approved in a referendum in the 2014 elections.
There's a reason referendums are not part of the standard blueprint for stadium campaigns.

Sternberg Speaks to Tampa Bay Business Group

Michael Sasso from the Tampa Tribune has the latest on Stu Sternberg's relationship with the Tampa Bay business community (hint: it's pretty good):
On Wednesday, Rays principal owner Stuart Sternberg and team president Matt Silverman gave an informal talk to the (Tampa Bay Partnership), which is a group of area businesses and local governments that tries to market the region to employers. The press wasn't allowed into the chat, but afterward Sykes provided the Tribune with a synopsis of what happened.

The partnership took no formal action on the stadium issue Wednesday.

As he's said in other venues recently, Sternberg told about 60 members of the partnership how Major League Baseball is frustrated with the slow pace of progress in the stadium stalemate with St. Petersburg.
Few other details were available about the meeting, but Sykes indicated some of the limited participation from interested local business groups was because of St. Pete's threat of legal action. 

Nevertheless, the business communitiy remains one of Sternberg's biggest allies and could ultimately help break the current stalemate should the Rays and St. Petersburg fail to find a friendly medium during direct negotiations.