Saturday, August 10, 2013

Times Endorses Kriseman for Mayor; Trib Endorses Foster

A recent shift on the Rays Stadium Saga wasn't enough to win Mayor Bill Foster the endorsement of the Tampa Bay Times in this month's mayoral election.  He did, however, pick up the endorsement from the more conservative Tampa Tribune editorial board.

The Times, the region's paper-of-record, endorsed former city councilman and state representative Rick Kriseman, mentioning his willingness to negotiate with the Rays as one of the reasons.  The Times Editorial Board opines Kriseman would talk to the team, "while protecting St. Petersburg's financial interests and trying to boost attendance at Tropicana Field."

Kriseman has long campaigned on the stadium issue and says he wants to fight to keep the Rays in St. Petersburg.  But he also favors letting the team search for sites in Hillsborough County.

Kriseman, Foster, and Kathleen Ford are currently fighting for the mayor's office; if no candidate secures 50% of the vote (current polls show they won't), the top two finishers will head to a run-off in November.

Friday, August 9, 2013

Buckhorn, Hagan Talk Stadium Saga and Subsidies

It was merely the opening statement, but Tampa Mayor Bob Buckhorn and Hillsborough Co. Commission Chairman Ken Hagan made a case Friday for the Rays to put up or shut up.

While two of the area's top officials don't even have permission to speak to the Rays yet, they're making plans to launch a stadium search committee to figure out how to get a stadium deal done in Downtown Tampa.   And they're calling on the Rays to put up huge sums of money to make it happen, too.

Buckhorn suggested the Rays should pay between $200 and $300 million for a new stadium - a figure that could be nearly half of the cost of a new facility, but also double what the team was previously willing to pay in 2008. 
For what it's worth, the Rays still aren't commenting on this week's developments and told me in January they had "no idea" how much they'd contribute - or make - from a new stadium.

And even more importantly, how much will Buckhorn's numbers change over the next few years?  Typically, they drop while a city's contributions tend to climb.

Now, in Buckhorn's defense, his office provided me the numbers on downtown TIF financing that would, in fact, likely bond between $100 and $150 million over 30 years.  It clears up that little tiff about the TIF from earlier this week.

But $300 million from the Rays is not only unlikely, it's also not nearly enough if Buckhorn keeps his word to only spend $100-$150 million in existing revenues.  Hagan has said no public financing for a stadium, so don't count on county revenues (until he changes his mind).

So maybe the stalemate is coming to an end...but it's still a "Stadium Standstill" because financing this deal will be darned-near impossible without huge public subsidies.

Oh, and one more question....with the Rays consistantly pulling in some of the top profits in baseball and MLB's national television revenue exploding and 14 more years left on the Trop's contract...why is everyone in such a rush to spend hundreds of millions of dollars to increase attendance by a few thousand people a night?

Chatting Stadium Saga on 10 News

Got a chance to chat Rays stadium financing on the 10 News morning show today:

Thursday, August 8, 2013

Hagan, Buckhorn to Discuss Stadium Finances for First Time

Tampa Mayor Bob Buckhorn and Hillsborough County Commissioner Ken Hagan regularly chat behind closed doors, but when they meet tomorrow morning, a horde of reporters will be waiting outside.

It'll be the first time the two officials catch up since St. Pete Mayor Bill Foster opened the floodgates on the Rays-to-Tampa talks.  Hopefully the conversation can finally shift a little bit to how anyone might be able to pay for a new stadium.

We're now learning Tampa's Dowtown TIF may only cover about $50 million in construction costs, rather than the $100 million we previously thought.  That leaves a mighty big financing gap if Tampa wants to build a stadium...and a mighty big mountain for Hagan and Buckhorn to climb.

Meanwhile, don't count out a possible Pinellas County stadium near the Howard Frankland Bridge.  The county's tourist development council (TDC), which we already knew had more available money that Hillsborough did, found out today they may have even more than they first realized:

"Pinellas County Commissioners were also shocked to hear from county administrator Bob LaSala that they might be able to get their hands on even more tourism dollars," wrote WMNF Radio.

Lasala said: “There is language in the state legislation that allows counties that have $600 million of sales subject to the bed tax to levy an additional 6th cent on the bed tax. The way that is done, county commission vote is taken and it would take five affirmative votes out of seven in order to do that.”

Increasing the bed tax could raise another $6 million a year, or enough to probably cover an additional $90 million in stadium construction - on top of the hundreds of millions in Pinellas bonding power that will be available once the Trop bonds are paid off.  (Legally, Hillsborough cannot raise its bed tax right now)

There are, however, lots of hungry mouths to feed in Pinellas too.  With a Clearwater Marina expansion, beach renourishment, and even possible spring training needs on the horizon, a new Rays stadium is not a top public financing priority to many folks in Pinellas, either.

Why Transit is More Important than Stadium Location

I've long preached that you cannot have a meaningful discussion about stadium sites without first discussing stadium financing.

But it's also important to realize you cannot start to discuss stadium sites without first discussing what Tampa Bay's transit picture will look like in 2025 (or 2035 or 2045).

While it's all well-and-good to figure out how many people currently live within a 30-minute drive of Carillon vs. a 30-minute drive of Downtown Tampa (hint: it's the same), the region's transportation picture will be drastically different by 2035.  And the presence of light rail and/or rapid-transit buses will reshape our impressions of a "reasonable" commute.

Earlier this year, Rays owner Stu Sternberg acknowledged "transit (is) the real difference-maker...it's a foregone conclusion: wherever we end up (with a new stadium)...there will be a stop there."

And forget just a "stop" - a new stadium could be a regional hub: think Penn Station and Madison Square Garden.  Transit really could be a difference-maker - even more than the stadium's location.

With an extensive transit footprint, not even Downtown St. Petersburg looks like a bad stadium site. Truth is, there would be no bad stadium site if the light rail could whisk you from Wesley Chapel to The Trop in under an hour.

I'm not saying a new stadium in Downtown St. Pete make sense, but successful transit would make our sprawling region look a lot smaller.

Yet despite huge momentum for light rail right now, Hillsborough County doesn't even have a referendum lined up for voters to weigh in on it.  And like a new baseball stadium, it doesn't have money for the project either, yet.

I've always thought that a stadium funding package could piggyback a transit referendum, just as Raymond James Stadium did with school funding back in 1996.  But Kevin Thurman, Executive Director at Connect Tampa Bay, tells me that's not likely for legislative and practical reasons.

Nevertheless, Florida has long been a petri dish of growth management experiments and before this region can worry about a new stadium, it needs to figure out its long-term transportation strategy.

There is no doubt transit provides a great value to a community. But if light rail is determined to be too costly for the value it provides, the region needs to figure out how it will address growth.  Otherwise, the 30-minute commute time from Downtown Tampa won't extend past Dale Mabry.

And just as the elected leaders in Tampa Bay need to take a hard, honest look at whether spending huge amounts of money on light rail is right for this region, they need to take the same hard, honest look at stadium costs.

Pro sports teams provide great value to a region's image, if nothing else. But at some point, the public cost outweighs the value...and the region needs to figure out how much it really wants to pay for these luxuries.

Tampa's $100 Million for a Stadium is Only Worth $50 Million

Leave it to the nation's top stadium subsidy watchdog, Neil deMaus, to pick out this nugget:
The $100 million in Community Redevelopment Area money (a slush TIF-style fund that earmarks downtown property taxes for development projects) that Tampa Mayor Bob Buckhorn wants to dedicate to a Rays stadium is actually worth $100 million over 30 years, not up front.

That’s a huge difference. Paid out over 30 years, $100 million is enough to finance maybe $50 million or so in upfront costs, depending on what interest rate you get on stadium bonds. Which means that if you assume a $600 million stadium and that Rays owner Stuart Sternberg will put in $200 million — a number he seems to have managed to get reified in the sports media, though so far as I can tell he came up with it out of thin air — there’d still be $350 million unaccounted for, even if Buckhorn manages to wrest the CRA money away from other projects eager to tap it.
If the Rays want to play in Tampa before 2027, that $50 million might cover the check to St. Pete for breaking their contract early.  Which means you may be looking at a $400 million funding deficit - way bigger than any rental car or hotel tax increase could cover.

Rays-to-Tampa Momentum: Day 4

Lots of opinion in the papers today after three days worth of Rays-to-Tampa talks...

In the Tampa Bay Times, the region's largest newspapers, it's all about pushing regional pride.  In fact, the editorial board mentioned some variation of the word "region" six times in six paragraphs.  That said, a new stadium may not get built without a regional approach - a regional tax, more specifically - so time to get talking now if the people want it to happen.

The Times also opined:
It took outside pressure for Foster to adjust his approach. He acknowledged to the Times editorial board this week that efforts by the county commissions in Pinellas and Hillsborough, and the St. Petersburg City Council, to break the stadium stalemate had an effect.
This comes as no surprise since public pressure is all part of the blueprint so many other teams have used to get stadia built on someone else's dime.  But it is nice to see Tampa and St. Pete cooperating (to a degree) rather than competing for this resource.

The editorial board of the Tampa Tribune wrote this morning that some outstanding questions need to be answered before plans for a new stadium progress too far...and they're right:
Will the team fare better in Tampa than in St. Petersburg, where attendance routinely ranks near the bottom despite winning teams? Will there be sufficient corporate support? Can the region financially support three major league sports franchises? Can a stadium be funded with minimal costs and limited risks to taxpayers?
I'm not sure the answers to these questions.  I have theories, but so does everyone.

The Trib also suggested the ever-popular rental car taxes, hotel taxes, and ticket surcharges could cover the public portion of a new stadium, as to avoid a significant burden on taxpayers.  Except, not only could these revenue streams be used to pay for other local needs, but I've explained before why ticket surcharges are the last thing an MLB team wants to use to finance a stadium.

Unless Tampa finds a way to reinvent the wheel and finance a stadium in ways no other team has done before, you're probably looking at a real tax committment (not my words)....or another stadium in Pinellas County, where hotel taxes bring in more revenue.

Wednesday, August 7, 2013

Rays-to-Tampa Momentum: Day 3

So lots of news today about Ken Hagan's proposed Hillsborough County stadium search committee....including from Mayor Bill Foster on sports radio today:
But a couple quick thoughts on what I'm reading:
  1. Hagan took my advice and said current Downtown Tampa land owners, like Lightning owner Jeff Vinik, shouldn't be on the committee for possible conflict-of-interest reasons.
  2. This will be at least the third public group to look at possible financing for a new stadium.  The first two - the ABC Coalition and the local chambers' stadium caucus - both indicated it would be near-impossible to get a stadium done in Tampa without significant new taxes.
Also interesting were comments from St. Petersburg council chair Karl Nurse, who reminded everyone in Tampa that on top of a $600 million price tag for a new stadium, they'd better budget a buyout of St. Pete's current contract if the Rays are going to move before 2027.

“I'm not convinced that moving 20 miles in any direction will have a huge impact on their attendance,” Nurse told the Trib. “Is it worth $500 or $600 million collectively? I don't know the answer to that.”

My WTSP-TV colleague Dave Wirth agrees:
Sure, blame all the usual suspects: bad location, bad stadium, bad economy, not enough corporate support. But the ugly truth could be we just don't have enough real baseball fans in the Tampa Bay area. Real fans who will pay to see the Rays play, no matter where they're playing.

And even with a new stadium in Tampa, there's no guarantee the team will draw there.

We may have to face facts.
A good friend of my station, Tampa land attorney Ron Weaver, speculated in the pages of the Times that there are lots of creative ways to fund a stadium that are worth exploring: rental car taxes, hotel taxes, ticket surcharges, premium concerts and conventions, etc.  Weaver knows a heck of a lot more about this stuff than I do, but I don't think the ideas are ways to close that $300-$400 million gap in stadium financing:
  1. Rental car tax increases require approval from the legislature and the chamber caucus already identified rental car and hotel tax increases as the major revenue streams for Tampa.  They're not enough to close the gap.
  2. Ticket surcharges ultimately mean the team is collecting less per ticket, so it's the last thing the Rays want.  If they wanted to pay for a stadium themselves, they'd take a loan from MLB.
  3. Concerts and conventions are nice, but you aren't going to convince new artists to go on tour.  So more likely, you'd just be prying events away from the Tampa Bay Times Forum, the Whatever-Its-Called-Now Amphetheater, and the Tampa Convention Center.  Basically, Tampa would be spending money to move big events from one venue to another one across town.
But the best brainstorming I read today came on Field of Schemes, where Neil deMause writes:
If there’s a lesson from the history of past stadium campaigns, it’s not to get locked in to dollar figures too early, or else the debate shifts from “Should we build this?” to “How can we fill this $__ million funding gap?”
One reaction you won't read is that of the Tampa Bay Rays.  They've declined comments all week.

St. Pete Mayoral Candidates Debate Rays

My WTSP colleague Beau Zimmer covered the St. Petersburg mayoral debate last night, and when it came to the Rays' Stadium Saga, all three candidates seemed to have been well-rehearsed on their answers.

"I’m very solid on our legal position if out sole objective were to keep the Rays here through 2027," said Mayor Foster, who made hordes of headlines this week with a softened stance on the team's desire to look at Tampa stadium sites.

"What is the objective after (2027)," Foster asked rhetorically.  "I guarantee if we do (nothing) there will be no Tampa Bay Rays in 2028. So if our objective is to let a longer-term commitment for the region those are the kinds of discussions I’ve been having with the Rays organization."

Meanwhile, Rick Kriseman, who has long been at-odds with Foster on the stadium issue, indicated he was flip-flopping because it was close to Election Day.

"Mr. Foster has had as many positions as Ben Zobrist," Kriseman said, "but hasn’t done them as well...This is an important issue…it is not a game, this is serious and it involves our city…and I have said from the beginning I think there are some things we can do to try to make this team more successful."

Kathleen Ford said, "Understand that the stadium is still not paid off. We have debt until 2025.  Understand that the operating costs are significant…so if the Rays do leave…who’s paying? And that’s the issue that needs to be addressed in any negotiations."

Foster, Ford, and Kriseman are all attorneys who have served on city council.  Foster won his first term in 2008 as mayor when he beat Ford in a run-off.

Another Bucs Blackout

Another year, another Bucs blackout.

This week's Buccaneers preseason game won't be on local TV because, once again, Raymond James Stadium won't be 85% full.  And even though the Glazers could have made fans happy by buying out a hundred thousand dollars of seats or so, they won't...so you won't get to watch Thursday night's game from anywhere except the stadium itself.

Not a good way to welcome in the 2013 season...but at least the Bucs owners aren't waging war with the state's elected leaders like the Dolphins' owner....

Tuesday, August 6, 2013

Rays-to-Tampa Momentum: Day 2

Yesterday, I wrote why Mayor Bill Foster's easing up on the Rays Stadium Saga may be good news.  It could mean progress on discussions of how to pay for a new venue.  But on the other hand, we are likely years away from figuring out that conundrum.

So where exactly are we at and what are the major players saying?

Hillsborough Commission Chairman Ken Hagan: A conservative Republican, Hagan once pledged not to use public funds for a stadium.  He told my WTSP colleague Grayson Kamm the "Tampa business community will step up to close that gap, with advertising deals, naming rights, and other agreements adding revenue."

However, advertising and naming right revenues typically go to the team, not to pay off a stadium.  So when you factor in the Rays' presumed $200 million contribution, there's a good chance those revenues would be part of the $200 million, not on top of it.

Expect Hagan's biggest contribution to be forming some sort of a search committee in Hillsborough County.  Hopefully they come up with an easier pill to swallow than these guys.

Tampa Mayor Bob Buckhorn: Out-of-state on vacation, Buckhorn issued a statement that said "it is time we broke the stalemate...It would be a complicated project, but it is worthy of a full and healthy discussion."   They mayor may not be the one to come up with the funding for a new stadium, but he has indicated he's up to the challenge.  Foster chuckles and calls it "backpedaling."

St. Petersburg Mayor Bill Foster: Hard to imagine a phone blowing up more around Tampa Bay today, but the mayor insists the news doesn't mean the Rays are leaving the Trop anytime soon.  "My position hasn't changed in protecting the interest of the taxpayers....we've really moved past 2027," he told WFLA.  That means he's still planning on enforcing the current contract...and until the Rays agree to his terms, they can't go and look in Tampa either.

The team's contract with St. Pete: It's still there.  It still runs through 2027.  And it still will require a signed agreement between the city and the team if the Rays want to look elsewhere.  Oh, and it's still not a "lease!"

Foster's opponents in the Aug. 27 election: “It's a shame that it takes the mayor's political future being on the line for him to care about the future of baseball in Tampa Bay," former councilman Rick Kriseman said in a statement.   He may have a point about the timing of this all, but Kriseman and Kathleen Ford saw this coming weeks ago.  (PS - they're all debating tonight)

Pinellas County: The Tampa Tribune's Michael Sasso reports, "Coincidentally, the Pinellas County Commission is expected to discuss how to divvy up some of its hotel bed taxes at a Tourist Development Council meeting this week. One possibility is redirecting some of the bed tax money now going to pay off Tropicana Field bonds toward a new potential stadium, Pinellas County Commission Chairman Ken Welch said." Pinellas County, home to Tampa Bay's beaches, brings in a lot more bed tax money than Hillsborough County.

Tampa Bay Times columnist John Romano: "There are still plenty of details to be worked out. For instance, an amendment to allow the Rays to look at stadium sites outside of St. Petersburg must be written. And a settlement to the Tropicana use agreement will also have to be negotiated if the Rays get funding for another stadium elsewhere...For today, at least, Foster has figured out it's not such a bad idea to pass the buck. Or several hundred million bucks."

Tampa Bay Rays: They've yet to comment.  But knowing the blueprint of how stadium deals get done, they have to be happy.
 

Monday, August 5, 2013

Foster Calls Tampa's Bluff on Rays Stadium

For the first time since his election almost four years ago, St. Petersburg Mayor Bill Foster says it is time for the Rays to explore stadium options in Tampa, according to a report from the Tampa Bay Times.

This is either a major Foster concession that reshapes the nature of the Stadium Saga…or it may merely be the mayor calling the bluffs of elected leaders across the bay.

According to the Mark Puente/Stephen Nohlgren story, "tepid attendance over the last few years has changed his thinking, Foster said Monday, in a remarkably candid interview with the Tampa Bay Times editorial board."

Foster's new revealation comes on the heels of recent news that St. Pete and the Rays have been hammering out the framework of a deal that could let them explore new stadium sites anywhere in Tampa Bay - one of Stu Sternberg's basic requests/demands in 2010.

But as we all know, location isn't the big problem in the Rays' Stadium Saga - funding is.

Could Foster, an attorney so keenly aware of how valuable leverage is in the stadium game, find a way to redirect some of the negative public opinions of him as an obstructionist at Tampa Mayor Bob Buckhorn and Hillsborough County Commissioner Ken Hagan?

"It's somewhat humorous to watch (County Commission Chairman Ken) Hagan and (Tampa Mayor Bob) Buckhorn kind of backpedaling a little bit because they were all wearing their finest trying to court the Rays to look over there,'' Foster told the Times. "Now that it might actually happen, you got Ken Hagan saying he's not going to commit any taxpayer money to it, which is naive."

Foster's referencing a comment Hagan made a few weeks ago that a taxpayer-funded stadium like Raymond James Stadium would never happen again.  And in Hagan's defense, he hasn't really changed his stance; he's never suggested a idea of how to pay for a new $600 million stadium. 

But credit Field of Schemes author Neil deMaus, who first speculated Foster may be taking the risk of letting the Rays look elsewhere, only to prove Pinellas County may be best-situated to keep the Rays in the long-term.

That said, regardless of which scenario is playing out right now, we are still a long way from the Rays being able to explore possible stadium sites in Hillsborough County.

That's because no deal is done yet on how St. Pete would guarantee the Rays looking elsewhere wouldn't make it easier for them to break their current contract.  And the Rays haven't agreed yet to the possible multi-million dollar price tag on exploring new stadium sites.

Again, Foster is an attorney, so there's no way he's going to simply let the Rays walk out on their contract - and obligations to St. Petersburg - without significant compensation.

But any Rays fan has to be happy with any sign of progress in the ongoing Stadium Stalemate (any fan, that is, except the two former councilmembers who have hopes of replacing Foster as mayor this fall).

Now if only Tampa Bay could come together to find a way to finance a stadium....the Rays wouldn't have to!

Sunday, August 4, 2013

Strong Weekend at Rays' Box Office

It may have taken a $2 kids night, a Joe Maddon Gnome giveaway, and the World Champion Giants visiting, but the Rays have posted four straight strong showings at the gate, including Sunday's sellout win.  (It doesn't hurt there was some great baseball and the Rays keep on winning)

The team's season average is now up to 18,476, which is a few hundred fans a game more than the 30th-ranked Marlins, but still far below last year's average at this point of 20,647.

There are certainly signs if the Rays can keep up their unbelievable play that they could continue to grow their audience into the fall.  But a lot of that depends on the buzz around the Buccaneers and Lightning, too.

No matter how you slice it, at least the Rays aren't getting the kind of press the Marlins are: disappointing news on the ballfield and embarrassing news in the stands.

For those of you keeping score at home - like Maury Brown with the Biz of Baseball - the Marlins are just a touch in front of the 1999 Rays in the hotly-contested race for worst-sophomore season in a new ballpark.

Thursday, August 1, 2013

Rays Supporters Cast Votes in St. Pete Mayoral Election (with Checkbooks)

While Rays executives aren't getting active (publicly) in this fall's St. Pete mayoral race like they have in previous political races, plenty of other local figures are making their support known with campaign contributions.

It's already been reported that Tampa Council Chairman Charlie Miranda supported Mayor Bill Foster's re-election campaign with a $100 check for Foster's "dedication to ensuring that contractual obligations are adhered to."

But also supporting Foster is developer Darryl LeClair, the Carillon/Mid-Pinellas stadium proponent, who gave the maximum $500 donation.  And Bob Byelick, chairman of the Clutch Hitters, the grass-roots Rays booster club, donated $250.  (make sure to read his letter in the Times this week)

Meanwhile, one of Foster's top threats, Rick Kriseman, has been leading the money race and is closing the gap in the polls as well.  The former St. Pete councilman, who says he'd work out a deal to let the Rays explore Tampa, received $500 from former Clutch Hitters president David Feaster.
 
Kriseman also received $50 from Tampa councilwoman Mary Mulhern and $500 from St. Pete councilman Charlie Gerdes, who crafted the failed contract amendment that would have opened the door for the Rays to explore Tampa.

And former ABC Coalition spokesman Craig Sher, who has always pushed for regional cooperation on the stadium front, chipped in $500 to Kriseman's coffer as well.

Many of the donations fall along party lines (Foster is a Republican; Kriseman is a Democrat), so some of the loyalties may not be stadium-driven at all.
 
But there doesn't seem to be much support among the baseball crowd for former councilwoman Kathleen Ford (also a Democrat).  Ford is the third legit contender for two spots in a mayoral run-off, but trails in fundraising and her most recent finance report showed no signs of any notable names from the many chapters of the Stadium Saga.

Rays Drop Ticket Prices for Kids, Draw Huge Wednesday Crowd

Maybe it is the economy, Stupid?

The last time the Rays gave away free tickets, the Trop sold out.  Then last night, all it took was almost-free $2 kids tickets to get 25,095 paid butts-in-seats.

It was enough to lift the team's season average to 17,916 and out of the MLB cellar.

For what it's worth, reader Mike M. said he hoped last night's crowd would at least reach 25k (mission accomplished), while reader B. Dufala didn't think lower ticket prices would make a difference.